top of page

day of glory

We've got the shield!!

Whether we keep it for one game or 20 games is of small moment to the thousands upon thousands of Hawkes Bay fans who travelled to Hamilton on the weekend of 24th September. For them this day was a great day in the history of rugby and nothing will erase the tremendous spirit of comradeship that existed wherever the 'Hawkeye Guys' gathered together that weekend.

That we did take the shield was undeniably the high point of the event, but overall, it was people, Hawkes Bay people, who made the mass invasion of Hamilton one of the greatest events in Hawkes Bay rugby. Never before, have so many gone so far, from one place, to see so few.

 

Estimates of the exodus to Hamilton to see the HB v Waikato Ranfurly Shield match vary between 10,000 and 13,000, but it is certain that the small winning margin did not reflect the tremendous difference of support for the two opposing teams. 

HB PHOTO NEWS, OCTOBER 1966

September 24th, 1966

After a gap of 13 years, the Waikato Rugby Football Union again had the pleasure of welcoming a Ranfurly Shield challenging team to Hamilton. Very much in a rebuilding stage, the province had most certainly had their ups and downs throughout the 1966 representative season, but the somewhat surprise 15-11 victory over Auckland (the Auks without Mac Herewini, Ron Rangi and Waka Nathan, on test duty with the All Blacks in Christchurch) had restored the balance and given a degree of hope to their faithful supporters.

The season had begun full of promise, with consecutive home victories against Counties (12-8), Auckland (16-11), Thames Valley (16-14) and North Auckland (16-13), bringing with the win, the Coronation Shield. Three defeats on the road followed; King Country-Wanganui (6-10, Te Kuiti - the combined unions then defeating the British Lions by 12-6 the following week), Taranaki (3-6, New Plymouth) and Bay of Plenty (6-19, Whakatane) and with the loss, the surrender of the Coronation Shield in defence one.

Even without their All Blacks, Auckland were expected to hold the shield, as the opinion was that this was not a great Waikato side in the circumstances, bereft of former stars the likes of Don and Ian Clarke, Rex Pickering or the current selector-coach, Ponty Reid. The relative ease with which Bay of Plenty had put Waikato away, did not install much faith in the Mooloo supporter and it was only the solid core of supporters that travelled to Eden Park who were rewarded with a thrilling game and a well deserved Waikato victory.

The challengers tore into their work with great enthusiasm and proved themselves capable of rising to the big occasion. The forwards won some good ball and the backs used it freely. When passing was not desirable, Dave Wood kicked with great precision and judgement and on the day, dictated terms most admirably. With a little more luck and more desire to finish, Waikato could have had an almost impregnable lead at half-time and even then, the game could have been safely sewn up some time before the end of the second spell. Auckland, allowed to stay in the game, made a barn-storming but unsuccessful late bid to hold the shield.

Shield success was blunted seven days later, when the British Lions turned in one of their best tour performances and ripped Waikato apart. The 20-9 win is attributable in large part to the legendary Irish midfield back, Mike Gibson, who scored one of the five tries scored by the Brits, Welshman, Dewi Bebb scoring a brace.

 

The defeat was decisive. The trouble for Waikato was simply this; they'd be on the road for a month in the South Island, before returning to Hamilton, where they would have to put the shield on the line just once for the remainder of the season, against the high-flying Hawkes Bay side, in some circles considered the best provincial outfit in New Zealand.

Waikato rallied and fought out a meritorious 0-0 draw with Wellington on Athletic Park. The verdict was still out, but a glimmer of hope was restored. Nothing much could be read into a 23-11 over Golden Bay-Motueka, but another large defeat, this time to Canterbury (0-17, Christchurch), put the wobbles back in the Waikato wheel. This was very much juxtaposed with victory by 13-9 over Southland, who after all had defeated the Lions in their tour opener, momentum lost again with an 8-17 loss to Otago on Carisbrook.

WAIKATO REPRESENTATIVES 1966 (v. BRITISH LIONS)

Back Row: David Flavell (Putaruru Athletic), Peter Billing (HHSOB), Rob Flannagan (HHSOB), Beau Guest (Matamata)

Middle Row: Gary Bremer (Putaruru Athletic), Joe Wright (Huntly COB), Brian Clarke (Kereone), Graeme Clarke (Kereone)

William McFarlane (Morrinsville UOB), R B Baldwin (Putaruru Athletic), Andy Johnson (Tokoroa)

Front Row: John Wood (Putaruru Athletic), Mr. Ponty Reid (Selector), Dave Wood (Captain/Putaruru Athletic)

Ian Paterson (HHSOB), Mr. D S Ensor (Asst. Coach), John Cresswell (HHSOB) 

So it was a confident Magpie team that headed for Hamilton, with All Blacks Tremain, Davis and MacRae in tow, along with future All Blacks Duncan and Thimbleby. None of the 41 players who represented the Waikato in 1966 ever played for the All Blacks. 

In spite of considerable territorial advantage, the Bay had trouble in breaking down the holders and getting points on the board. Eventually the Magpies - the better side on paper - confirmed their favouritism and ground out a 6-0 win courtesy of a much debated first-half penalty to Bishop and a late try to Bill Davis. 

The first points came following 25 yard drop out by Waikato which went directly into touch. From the resulting scrum, Paewai executed a prefect pass - without the ball - which was still in the scrum, luring the Waikato loose forwards offside. The move caused considerable outcry from some of the game's purists, believing the move to be 'cheating play'.

Speaking at the Hamilton Old Boys annual rugby dinner several days later, Auckland author and journalist, T. P. McLean was heavily critical of the move; "When a team sets to work on a rugby field by deliberately cheating, it is a serious concern. Paewai has very considerable ability, but what abilities can he develop if he is coached into this sort of play?"

As was pointed out after the event; if the Waikato flanker who charged through offside had been watching the ball properly, he would never have fallen into the trap. Controversy aside, it was never rated as a grand game of rugby, a dour and tight affair in fact. Tom Johnson regards it as one of the poorest matches he ever played in and Neil Thimbleby says that the winning of the shield was somewhat of an anti-climax.

"I got bigger thrills in some of the matches where we retained it."

Neil Thimbleby (Shield Fever, Lindsay Knight)

A penalty goal to Ian Bishop (left) and a try to Bill Davis...and the shield was back after 34 years!

Hawkes Bay skipper, Kel Tremain, has a few words to say to the crowd in Hamilton, having received the Ranfurly Shield from Waikato captain, Dave Wood.

Derek Olsen

I had the last 2 flagons of beer in Hamilton that night, the HB fans had drunk the town dry. They lasted about 20 seconds after Ant Burkett and I entered a Hamilton pub with them. Great game, great era.

BACK IN NAPIER!

Kel Tremain shows the Ranfurly Shield to the Napier partisan (left) and an artists depiction of Bill Davis' winning try, the cover of the 'Leopard History of Ranfurly Shield Rugby' (c) 1967.

A week after winning the Ranfurly Shield from Waikato, Hawkes Bay rounded out their season by suffering a 6-20 defeat at the hands of Wellington on Athletic Park. Two tries of rare quality scored by Denis Smith, earned him a spot in the 1966 'Almanack NZ XV', alongside provincial team-mates Ian MacRae and Kel Tremain (pictured at left after the Wellington match).

The Athletic Park fixture would be the last occasion in which Gerry Stone and David Kirkpatrick would put on the black and white jersey of Hawkes Bay.

Stone was one of the unsung heroes of the shield victory, encapsulated by his try saving tackle on Waikato lock, Graeme Clarke. 'Gal' Stone hit him so hard, the ball was spilled as Clarke was over the line and about to dot down.

Kirkpatrick, one of the famous brothers from Poverty Bay, was an extremely fast and useful all-purpose forward, who many have often suggested should most certainly have also worn the black jersey of his country.

Max Loughlin (first five-eighth in the shield win) was selected for the Bay again in 1967, but injury not only cut short his season, but unfortunately his career. His spot in the Ranfurly Shield side from 1967 onward went to the returning Blair Furlong, lured back to the Bay when a job was found for him at Rothmans in Napier.

THE 1966 HAWKES BAY RUGBY SIDE, WINNERS OF THE RANFURLY SHIELD

Back row: Tony Waldin (NHSOB), Denis Smith (Clive), Mick Duncan (HHSOB), Ian Bishop (Waipukurau HSOB), Gus Meech (NHSOB)

Middle row: Lou Cooper (MAC), Gary Condon (Colenso-Pirates), Derek Snow (Napier Tech OB), David Kirkpatrick (Porangahau)

Tony Dick (NHSOB), Karaan Crawford (MAC), Gerry Stone (Ruahine)

Seated: Max Loughlin (Marist), Ian MacRae (Marist), Mr. Wally Bramwell (Chairman, HBRFU), Kel Tremain (Captain/NHSOB)

Mr. Colin Le Quesne (Selector), Tom Johnson (Marist), Mr. Ian Hay (Masseur), Neil Thimbleby (Marist), Bill Davis (Taradale)

In front: Hepa Paewai (Dannevirke Aotea), John Nuku (Tamatea)

Absent: Gary Watts (Napier Tech OB)

bottom of page